The recent settlement between ABC News and former President Donald Trump over a defamation lawsuit has ignited a debate about potential chilling effects on media criticism. The lawsuit stemmed from comments made by ABC News host George Stephanopoulos during an interview where he stated Trump was "found liable for rape." Although ABC News maintained a strong legal position, they chose to settle with Trump for $15 million and issue a statement of regret.
Legal analysts and media figures have expressed concerns about the implications of this settlement. Barbara McQuade, MSNBC legal analyst, worries about the potential chilling effect on future criticism of Trump. She points out that while settlements are not admissions of guilt, the accompanying statement of regret and the substantial financial payout could discourage others from speaking out against the former president.
Harry Litman, LA Times legal columnist, questions the involvement of ABC's boardroom in the decision, speculating that the timing of the settlement, close to Trump's potential return to the presidency, might have played a role. He raises concerns about public trust in both the criminal justice system and the media's ability to report truthfully if outlets fear legal repercussions from Trump.
MSNBC guests express concerns about the potential impact of ABC's settlement with Trump on media criticism. (Screenshot/MSNBC)
Other media commentators have also voiced their disapproval of the settlement. Symone Sanders, MSNBC host, expressed disagreement with the decision, while Democratic election lawyer Marc E. Elias criticized ABC News for what he perceived as capitulation to Trump.
As part of the settlement, ABC News will donate $15 million to a future presidential foundation and museum established by or for Trump, and will also cover $1 million in his legal fees. An editor's note expressing regret has been added to the original online article that sparked the lawsuit.
George Stephanopoulos during a broadcast of ABC's "This Week." (ABC/Paula Lobo via Getty Images)
The settlement has sparked discussions on various social media platforms. Legal analyst Norm Eisen and USA Today columnist Michael J. Stern have both expressed doubts about the necessity of the settlement, given the strength of ABC's case. Justin Baragona, a journalist for The Independent, described the settlement as setting a "worrisome precedent."
McQuade, in a separate discussion with MSNBC's Ali Velshi, reiterated her concerns about the potential chilling effect on media coverage of a future Trump administration. She emphasized the importance of a free press, especially when dealing with an administration known for targeting its critics.
